Buyer Tips
Moving From New York to Central Florida?10 Things You Need to Know Before Buying a Home
I've lived in Florida for more than 40 years and called Clermont home since 2002. Here's what I tell every New Yorker thinking about making the move.
Thinking about trading New York winters, snow shovels, and high property taxes for sunshine, palm trees, and a Florida lifestyle? You're not alone!
But buying a home in Central Florida is very different from buying one in New York. Here are 10 things you really need to know before making the move.
Don't Just Buy the House. Buy the Lifestyle.
New Yorkers are often amazed by how much house they can get for their money in Central Florida. Suddenly, that four-bedroom home with a three-car garage and a screened-in lanai seems possible! But bigger isn't always better. Sometimes being five minutes from your favorite activities is worth more than having an extra bedroom. Do you imagine riding your golf cart downtown for dinner? Walking along a beautiful lake? Playing pickleball with friends? Spending weekends at Disney? Choose the community that fits the lifestyle you want, not just the house that checks the most boxes.
Clermont, Winter Garden, and Horizon West Have Very Different Vibes
Historic Downtown Winter Garden is filled with restaurants, boutiques, events, and a popular farmers market. It's also known for its golf cart lifestyle — residents in certain designated areas can take their golf carts downtown for dinner, shopping, and entertainment. If you love a lively, walkable historic downtown, Winter Garden deserves a look.
A local Winter Garden real estate agent can help you explore neighborhoods that fit the lifestyle you're looking for.
Clermont has been my home since 2002, and I absolutely love it here. Yes, Florida has hills! Clermont is known for beautiful lakes, rolling hills, scenic trails, and an active outdoor lifestyle. Our downtown waterfront along Lake Minneola hosts festivals, markets, and community events. If you love boating, biking, walking, or just being outside, Clermont has a lot to offer.
Horizon West is one of the newer, rapidly growing areas of southwest Orange County. You'll find modern communities, trendy restaurants, shopping, and convenient access to Walt Disney World. The Hamlin area is particularly popular for its dining and entertainment options. If you're dreaming of a newer home and easy access to Disney, Horizon West may be your perfect fit.
Are Florida HOAs Really That Controlling?
This is one of the biggest concerns I hear from New Yorkers. In many communities, yes — HOA rules may regulate exterior modifications, landscaping, parking, rentals, and property maintenance. But those beautifully maintained neighborhoods you love often look that way because their HOAs enforce community standards. My advice? Read the governing documents BEFORE buying. If you prefer fewer restrictions, let's find a community that fits your lifestyle.
What Is a CDD Fee, and Why Should You Care?
CDD stands for Community Development District — a special-purpose local government that can finance and maintain community infrastructure such as roads, stormwater systems, landscaping, and recreational facilities. CDD assessments are commonly collected through your property tax bill and are generally in addition to your HOA dues, not instead of them. Two homes with the same purchase price can have very different monthly ownership costs. Always ask about the current assessment and outstanding infrastructure debt before purchasing.
Is Homeowners Insurance Cheaper in Central Florida Than on the Coast?
Generally speaking, inland locations like Clermont and Winter Garden can have advantages over coastal properties. But that doesn't mean we're immune to hurricanes or expensive insurance. Your premium depends on roof age and condition, home construction and age, wind-mitigation features, and coverage limits. Always obtain an actual insurance quote before purchasing. And remember — standard homeowners policies generally don't cover flooding. Flood insurance is usually separate.
The Florida Property Tax Surprise Nobody Wants
DO NOT assume the property taxes shown on a Florida real estate listing are what you'll pay after buying the home. Florida's homestead exemption and Save Our Homes assessment limitations can keep longtime homeowners' taxable values significantly below current market values. When a property changes ownership, those limitations generally reset and the property is reassessed. That means your future property taxes could be substantially higher — sometimes hundreds of dollars more per month. Make sure your lender estimates your property taxes for the year AFTER purchase.
Florida Salaries Are Often Lower Than New York Salaries
Yes, Florida has no individual state income tax. But salaries in Central Florida can be considerably lower than comparable positions in New York. If you're relocating for work, make sure you understand your actual earning potential before establishing your homebuying budget. If you're keeping a remote job, confirm your employer allows you to work from Florida. Know your salary and buying power before falling in love with a house.
What Is Living in Central Florida Really Like?
Summer is HOT. And humid. Personally, I consider our three hottest months hibernation season! But spring, fall, and winter? That's when Central Florida really shines — outdoor dining, farmers markets, boating, golf, pickleball, festivals, and beautiful days exploring everything Florida has to offer. And here's something funny that happens after you've lived here a few years: eventually, 70 degrees starts feeling like the Arctic North. Trust me — you'll be reaching for a sweater while the tourists are wearing shorts.
Should You Rent Before Buying in Central Florida?
Not necessarily. If you've visited Central Florida, have your employment lined up, understand your budget, and know you can handle our summer humidity, you may be ready to buy. But I strongly recommend spending time exploring different communities before making that decision. Visit Downtown Clermont. Have dinner in Winter Garden. Explore Horizon West and Hamlin. Drive through neighborhoods. A home can look amazing online, but you need to experience the neighborhood.
Talk to a Realtor BEFORE Visiting New-Construction Models
Central Florida has some incredible new-construction communities. But the friendly sales representative in the model home works for the builder, not for you. Builder policies regarding Realtor registration and compensation vary, and some require your agent to accompany you on your first visit. That's why I recommend speaking with a local Realtor before visiting models or registering on builder websites. An experienced buyer's agent can help you compare communities, understand builder incentives, evaluate CDD and HOA costs, and navigate the purchase process.
For the right person, moving from New York to Central Florida is absolutely worth it. If you have your employment figured out, understand your budget, enjoy visiting Florida, and can handle our summer humidity, there's a very good chance you'll love living here.
But don't just buy the biggest house you can afford. Buy the lifestyle you've been dreaming about — whether that's morning walks along Lake Minneola, golf cart rides through Downtown Winter Garden, or weekends enjoying Disney.
Karen's Tip
There's no single perfect community for everyone — but there may be a perfect community for you.
Before you fall in love with a house online, spend time in the neighborhoods you're considering. Visit Downtown Clermont. Have dinner in Winter Garden. Explore Horizon West and Hamlin. Drive through neighborhoods and check out the grocery stores, traffic patterns, and nearby activities.
And please — talk to a local Realtor before visiting new-construction model homes. The sales rep in the model works for the builder, not for you.
Explore Communities
Ready to Explore Central Florida?
Hi, I'm Karen Tefft — Broker/Owner of Karen + Co Realty. I've called Clermont home since 2002 and I've been helping buyers navigate Central Florida for over 24 years.
Whether you're just starting to dream about moving south or you're already searching for homes, I'm happy to answer your questions. No pressure. No sales pitch. Just straightforward advice from someone who knows and loves this area.
Karen Tefft | Broker/Owner
Karen + Co Realty
Clermont · Winter Garden · Horizon West · Minneola
KarenandCoRealty.comKaren@KarenandCoRealty.com